Evidence analysisOctober 19, 2026Evidence
Indonesian Author Faces Blasphemy Probe for Short Stories

FreedomWitness Evidence Engine: This is an AI-assisted original analysis built from the linked source and available public source context. It separates evidence from interpretation and may challenge conventional framing only where the evidence supports it. It is not a copied article.
Evidence Dossier: Indonesian Author Faces Blasphemy Probe over Short Story Collection
What is Established
In September 2026, Indonesian police opened an investigation into Feby Indirani, the author of the short story collection Memburu Muhammad (Hunting for Muhammad), on allegations of blasphemy. The inquiry followed the cancellation of an event featuring Indirani at a literary festival organized by Bogor Literary Week. The cancellation occurred amid pressure associated with the Front Persaudaraan Islam (Islamic Brotherhood Front, FPI), a group reportedly threatening to disrupt the event.
Feby Indirani is known for literary work that often engages with themes around Islam, women’s rights, and marginalized groups. After the event cancellation, she experienced significant online harassment, including sexualized and gender-based attacks. Women supporting her publicly online faced similar harassment.
The Jakarta Metropolitan Police decided to proceed with an investigation based on social media allegations that Memburu Muhammad contained blasphemous content. The Indonesian Ministry of Religious Affairs described the book as containing sensitive material potentially offensive to religious believers.
High-profile religious figures, including leaders from the Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI), Muhammadiyah social organization, and an official associated with Nahdlatul Ulama, publicly backed calls for a blasphemy investigation.
Indonesia’s recently promulgated Criminal Code no longer uses the term “blasphemy” but categorizes related offenses as expressions of hostility against others’ religions or beliefs, punishable by up to five years in prison.
What the Source Claims
The Human Rights Watch report highlights concerns that the blasphemy probe serves as a form of censorship that risks silencing free expression, particularly of women writers addressing religious and social issues. It emphasizes that Indonesian authorities have obligations under international human rights law to protect freedom of expression and to investigate harassment and threats against authors rather than focus on prosecuting alleged blasphemy in fictional works.
According to Human Rights Watch, the intervention by FPI in the literary event and the subsequent cancellation exemplify the challenges faced by authors and organizers due to intimidation by Islamist groups. A representative of FPI stated a general principle upholding constitutional rights but underscored that expression must respect religious and public values, without expressly confirming involvement in the event cancellation.
What May Be Missing from the Usual Framing
There is limited publicly available information about the specific content within Memburu Muhammad that triggered allegations of blasphemy, beyond references to “sensitive material.” The precise nature of the disputed passages, whether they are critical, satirical, or interpretative discussions of Islam, is not detailed in the source.
The motives and internal dynamics of involved parties—such as event organizers, FPI members, police investigators, and religious leaders—are not extensively explored. Particularly absent is an investigation into whether the criminal justice response might reflect broader political or social pressures, beyond the legal text.
The report does not provide evidence on how widespread public opinion stands on this case within Indonesia, nor does it detail the stance of other civil society groups, religious minorities, or literary communities.
Competing Evidence or Uncertainty
The only statement from the FPI rejects outright confirmation of interference in the literary festival but reiterates respect for constitutional rights tempered by religious and public norms. This response indicates some ambiguity about FPI’s formal role in the cancellation, inviting uncertainty about direct versus indirect influence.
The Ministry of Religious Affairs’ description of the book as “sensitive” and potentially offensive suggests a government perception of the material as problematic, raising questions about the state’s criteria for regulating expression relating to religion.
The shift in Indonesia’s Criminal Code from the term “blasphemy” to a redefined offense category introduces legal complexities. The extent to which this reformulation has impacted enforcement practices, including the threshold for criminal prosecutions, remains unclear from the evidence presented.
Online harassment patterns indicate societal tensions around gender and expression but are difficult to quantify or fully understand without broader sociological data.
Why It Matters
This case raises significant questions about the balance between protecting religious sensitivities and upholding freedom of expression, particularly in a diverse, multi-religious society like Indonesia’s. It highlights the risks that legal frameworks and social pressures may pose to literary freedom and to the safety of female writers and activists.
The probe exemplifies how legal actions may be triggered or intensified by non-state actors wielding social and political influence, in this instance through threats of disruption and public accusations facilitated via social media.
It underscores the challenges governments face in ensuring that criminal laws concerning religion do not become tools for censorship or repression of dissenting voices, especially those advocating for marginalized communities or gender equality.
The episode also demonstrates the potential harms of targeted online harassment and the need for effective law enforcement responses to harassment and intimidation online, as distinct from investigations of artistic or literary content.
What to Verify Next
- Detailed content analysis of Memburu Muhammad to clarify which elements are considered blasphemous or offensive under Indonesian law.
- Statements or positions from Indonesian literary bodies, press freedom organizations, and women’s rights groups on this specific case and its broader implications.
- Official police or judicial documents to understand the legal basis for the investigation and any subsequent charges.
- Further clarification from the Front Persaudaraan Islam (FPI) regarding its role or influence in the event cancellation and its views on freedom of expression.
- Independent surveys or public opinion data on societal attitudes toward blasphemy laws, religious criticism, and the protection of authors’ rights in Indonesia.
While this dossier summarizes current verified information and outlines key questions, readers are encouraged to consult the original Human Rights Watch report for full context and updates as the situation develops.
Source & verification
Primary source: Human Rights Watch News · October 19, 2026
FreedomWitness links to the original source so readers can inspect the underlying material and judge the context for themselves.
Continue reading

Loss to follow-up during tuberculosis treatment and 5-year mortality in Brazil: A target trial emulation
Loss to follow-up during tuberculosis treatment and 5-year mortality in Brazil: evidence dossier What is established Tuberculosis (TB) remains a leading cause of infectious…

Disagreement doesn’t have to be toxic
Evidence Dossier: The Nature and Practice of Disagreement What is established Disagreement is a common and unavoidable part of social life, extending beyond politics…

Business professor? Perhaps more ‘detective of human behavior.’
Lauren Cohen: Investigating the Social Dynamics Behind Financial Markets This evidence dossier explores insights from an interview and profile published by the Harvard Gazette…